Phantom Vehicle Motorcycle Accidents in Alabama: The Driver May Be Gone, But Your Claim Doesn't Have to Be
When you hear “hit-and-run,” you probably picture a driver hitting someone and taking off. But for motorcyclists, a driver doesn’t have to make contact to cause a serious crash.
Maybe a car drifts into your lane and forces you onto the shoulder. A driver turns left in front of you, and you lay the bike down trying to avoid them. A truck loses a piece of lumber on the interstate, leaving you nowhere to go.
The vehicle that caused the crash may never stop. You may never know who was driving. But that doesn’t necessarily mean you’re out of options.
Alabama law allows injured riders to pursue certain claims involving unidentified, or “phantom,” vehicles. In some cases, your own Uninsured Motorist (UM) coverage may provide compensation for medical bills, lost income, pain and suffering, and other losses caused by the crash.
What Is a Phantom Vehicle Motorcycle Accident?
A phantom vehicle motorcycle accident happens when an unidentified driver or vehicle causes a rider to crash but leaves the scene or is never identified.
Sometimes there’s contact between the vehicles before the driver leaves. Other times, the driver creates a dangerous situation that forces the motorcyclist to react, even though the two vehicles never touch.
For example, a phantom vehicle accident could involve:
A car changing lanes into a motorcycle’s path
A driver turning left in front of an oncoming rider
A vehicle suddenly braking or swerving
A truck dropping lumber, tools, furniture, or other cargo into the road
An unidentified driver forcing a motorcyclist off the roadway
In each of these situations, the other driver’s actions may have caused the crash even if that driver was never identified.
Can You Make a Claim If the Other Driver Is Never Found?
Potentially, yes.
Alabama’s Uninsured Motorist statute requires insurers to offer UM/UIM coverage unless the named insured rejects it in writing. This coverage is designed to provide a source of recovery when someone is injured by a driver who doesn’t have adequate insurance, and it can also come into play when the responsible driver can’t be identified.
Alabama courts have recognized this issue for decades. In Wilbourn v. Allstate Insurance Co., the Alabama Supreme Court acknowledged that an unknown hit-and-run driver can qualify as an uninsured motorist for purposes of UM coverage.
That means the fact that the driver disappeared doesn’t automatically end your ability to pursue a claim.
What If the Other Vehicle Never Hit the Motorcycle?
This is where phantom vehicle claims can get confusing.
Imagine you’re riding on I-65 when a distracted driver starts merging into your lane. You swerve to avoid being hit, lose control, and go down. The other vehicle never touches your motorcycle and keeps driving.
The lack of contact doesn’t necessarily prevent you from pursuing a claim.
In Walker v. GuideOne Specialty Mutual Insurance Co., the Alabama Supreme Court addressed restrictions insurers attempted to place on phantom vehicle claims. The Court held that policy provisions imposing requirements more restrictive than Alabama’s uninsured motorist statute were unenforceable.
For riders, the important point is that a no-contact crash can still be caused by another driver. What matters is being able to show what happened and how that driver’s actions led to the wreck.
What About Debris in the Road?
Road debris is especially dangerous for motorcyclists. Something a car might drive over or around can cause a rider to lose control almost instantly.
Alabama courts have addressed several cases involving debris or substances in the roadway that were believed to have come from unidentified vehicles.
In Khirieh v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., a truck bench seat was found lying in interstate traffic. The Alabama Supreme Court determined there was enough evidence to reasonably infer that it had fallen from an unidentified vehicle, allowing the plaintiff to pursue a UM claim.
In Franks v. Alfa Mutual Insurance Co. and Alfa Mutual Insurance Co. v. Beard, Alabama courts addressed crashes involving gravel in the roadway and found there was evidence from which a jury could conclude the gravel came from an unidentified vehicle.
Similarly, in Jones v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., evidence that an oil slick may have originated from an unknown vehicle was enough to support a phantom vehicle claim.
These cases matter for motorcyclists because roadway debris comes in many forms. A 2x4, ladder, piece of furniture, construction material, or other object that falls from a vehicle can cause a devastating crash. If the evidence points to the debris coming from an unidentified vehicle, there may still be a path to recovery.
Your UM/UIM Coverage May Apply Beyond Your Car
Another common misunderstanding is that UM/UIM coverage only protects you when you’re driving the particular vehicle listed on the policy.
That isn’t always the case.
Alabama courts have recognized that UM/UIM coverage can be personal in nature. In Peachtree Casualty Insurance Co. v. Sharpton, the Alabama Supreme Court explained that UIM coverage insures the person rather than the vehicle.
Depending on the policy and circumstances, coverage may be available when you’re:
Riding your motorcycle
Driving a car
Riding as a passenger
Riding a bicycle
Walking as a pedestrian
There may also be situations where more than one UM/UIM coverage applies. Alabama permits stacking of UM/UIM coverage in certain circumstances, which can increase the amount of insurance available for a serious injury claim.
What Should You Do After a Phantom Vehicle Motorcycle Crash?
Evidence matters in any motorcycle accident, but it can be especially important when the driver who caused the crash is gone.
If you’re involved in a crash with an unidentified vehicle, try to:
Call law enforcement and report what happened
Take photos and video of the scene
Photograph or preserve roadway debris when it’s safe to do so
Get names and contact information for witnesses
Seek medical care for your injuries
Notify your insurance company of the crash
Speak with an attorney familiar with motorcycle and UM/UIM claims before giving a recorded statement
A phantom vehicle case often depends on being able to show that another vehicle caused the crash. Witness statements, photographs, debris, police reports, surveillance footage, dashcam footage, and other evidence can help establish what happened.
The Driver Is Gone. Your Options May Not Be.
A driver doesn’t get a free pass simply because they kept going.
Alabama law recognizes claims involving unidentified drivers, including some no-contact crashes and accidents caused by debris from unknown vehicles. When UM/UIM coverage applies, it may provide an important source of compensation even when the responsible driver is never found.
At Roden Motorcycle Lawyers, we help injured riders determine what insurance coverage may be available after a crash, including claims involving phantom vehicles and uninsured motorists.
Comments